G20 AND Artificial Intelligence


AI Policy News - 2024 G20 Summit


Understand what the G20 is and what Brasil's responsibilities are

 

Until November 30, 2024, Brasil holds the presidency of the G20, a group that brings together the world's largest economies - 19 countries, plus the African Union and the European Union.

 

Throughout this period, Brasil will be responsible for coordinating the G20 and organizing technical meetings, ministerial conferences and the next summit of heads of State, which will happen on November 18 and 19, 2024, in Rio de Janeiro.

 

We have produced this e-book with the aim of objectively organizing the main information about the G20 and the Brazilian presidency this year, in order to make the content more accessible.

 

In the e-book you can find information on what the G20 is, its backgroun, member countries, how it works, how the Finance and Sherpas Tracks are structured, the G20 Social and the responsibilities and priorities of the Brazilian presidency, based on the slogan "building a more just world and a sustainable planet".

  

The e-book is available for download in three languages: Spanish, English and Portuguese. Check it out.


Harnessing Artificial Intelligence for Social Equity and Sustainable Development

Brazil will host the G20 in 2024 and one of the focuses of the Digital Economy Working Group is “Artificial Intelligence for Sustainable Development and Reduction of Inequality”, to address the social and political impacts of the advancement of digital technologies.

 

The G20 Side Event on this topic will discuss challenges arising from the uneven global distribution of AI assets and infrastructure and potential solutions to equip governments and relevant stakeholders, including the private sector and civil society, with the capabilities and tools necessary to face such challenges. . . .


AI Policy News - 2023 G20 Summit



AI Provision (par. 61)


G20 AI Guidelines (2019)


Ministers in charge of trade and digital economy issues pose Saturday during a G20 ministerial meeting in Tsukuba, Ibaraki Prefecture. | KYODO (June 2019)
Ministers in charge of trade and digital economy issues pose Saturday during a G20 ministerial meeting in Tsukuba, Ibaraki Prefecture. | KYODO (June 2019)

Ministers from the Group of 20 major economies Saturday kicked off two days of meetings on trade and the digital economy, during which they agreed on guiding principles for using artificial intelligence. They also faced another round of discussions likely to highlight divisions over trade issues such as reform of the World Trade Organization.

The ministers agreed on the AI principles, which are created based on those adopted last month by the 36-member OECD and an additional six countries.

The G20 guidelines call for users and developers of AI to be fair and accountable, with transparent decision-making processes and to respect the rule of law and values including privacy, equality, diversity and internationally recognized labor rights.

[More]

 


Background

The 18th G20 Heads of State and Government Summit will take place on 9th-10th September 2023 in New Delhi. The Summit will be a culmination of all the G20 processes and meetings held throughout the year among ministers, senior officials, and civil societies. A G20 Leaders’ Declaration will be adopted at the conclusion of the New Delhi Summit, stating Leaders’ commitment towards the priorities discussed and agreed upon during the respective ministerial and working group meetings. 

 


How G20 Works


  • The G20 Presidency steers the G20 agenda for one year and hosts the Summit. The G20 consists of two parallel tracks: the Finance Track and the Sherpa Track. Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors lead the Finance Track while Sherpas lead the Sherpa Track after Finance Track
  • The G20 process from the Sherpa side is coordinated by the Sherpas of member countries, who are personal emissaries of the Leaders. Finance Track is led by Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors of the member countries. Within the two tracks, there are thematically oriented working groups in which representatives from the relevant ministries of the members as well as from invited/guest countries and various international organisations participate.
  • The Finance Track is mainly led by the Ministry of Finance. These working groups meet regularly throughout the term of each Presidency. The Sherpas oversee negotiations over the course of the year, discussing agenda items for the Summit and coordinating the substantive work of the G20.
  • In addition, there are Engagement Groups which bring together civil societies, parliamentarians, think tanks, women, youth, labour, businesses and researchers of the G20 countries.
  • The Group does not have a permanent secretariat. The Presidency is supported by the Troika – previous, current and incoming Presidency. During India’s Presidency, the troika will comprise Indonesia, India and Brazil, respectively.

Civil 20



Civil20 (C20) Engagement Group was launched as an official G20 Engagement Group in 2013, though Civil Society engagement among the G20 member countries had started in 2010. C20 provides a platform for Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) around the world to bring forth a non-government and non-business voice to G20. It provides space through which global CSOs can contribute in a structured and sustained manner to the G20.

 

The Civil20 India website is now live and more details are available through the following link : www.civil20.net

 

For more information, please visit:

Twitter: https://twitter.com/C20EG

Instagram: https://instagram.com/civil20india2023?igshid=Zjc2ZTc4Nzk=

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/c20eg


About the C20


 



Think20


Think20 (T20), as an official G20 Engagement Group, was initiated during the Mexican Presidency in 2012. It serves as an “idea bank” for the G20 by bringing together think tanks and high-level experts to discuss relevant international socio-economic issues. T20 recommendations are synthesized into policy briefs and presented to G20 working groups, ministerial meetings, and leaders’ summit to help the G20 deliver concrete policy measures.

 

The T20 India website is now live and more details are available through the following link : https://t20ind.org

 

For more information, please visit:

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/T20orgIndia/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/t20org/

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/t20india/

Twitter: https://twitter.com/T20org

Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@Think20India


G20 Leaders Statement 2022 and AI


We acknowledge that affordable and high-quality digital connectivity is essential for digital inclusion and digital transformation, while a resilient, safe and secure online environment is necessary to enhance confidence and trust in the digital economy. We recognize the importance of policies to create an enabling, inclusive, open, fair and non-discriminatory digital economy that fosters the application of new technologies, allows businesses and entrepreneurs to thrive, and protects and empowers consumers, while addressing the challenges, related to digital divides, privacy, data protection, intellectual property rights, and online safety. We acknowledge the importance to counter disinformation campaigns, cyber threats, online abuse, and ensuring security in connectivity infrastructure. We remain committed to further enable data free flow with trust and promote cross-border data flows. We will advance a more inclusive, human-centric, empowering, and sustainable digital transformation. We also reaffirm the role of data for development, economic growth and social well-being.


G20 Leaders Statement 2021 and AI


Well aware of the benefits stemming from the responsible use and development of trustworthy human-centered Artificial Intelligence (AI), we will advance the implementation of the G20 AI Principles, while considering the specific needs of MSMEs and start-ups to encourage competition and innovation, as well as diversity and inclusion, and the importance of international cooperation to promote research, development and application of AI. We welcome the G20 Policy Examples on How to Enhance the Adoption of AI by MSMEs and Start-ups.

 

We acknowledge the importance of data free flow with trust and cross-border data flows. We reaffirm the role of data for development. We will continue to work on addressing challenges such as those related to privacy, data protection, security and intellectual property rights, in accordance with the relevant applicable legal frameworks. We will also continue to further common understanding and to work towards identifying commonalities, complementarities and elements of convergence between existing regulatory approaches and instruments enabling data to flow with trust, in order to foster future interoperability. Recognizing the responsibility of digital service providers, we will work in 2022 towards enhancing confidence in the digital environment by improving internet safety and countering online abuse, hate speech, online violence and terrorism while protecting human rights and fundamental freedoms. We remain committed to protecting the most vulnerable, and acknowledge the G20 High Level Principles for Children Protection and Empowerment in the Digital Environment, drawn from the OECD Recommendation on Children in the Digital Environment and other relevant tools, such as the ITU 2020 Guidelines on Child Online Protection.


G20 Leaders Statement 2020 and AI


Digital Economy: Connectivity, digital technologies, and policies have played a key role in strengthening our response to the pandemic and facilitating the continuation of economic activity. We take note of the Policy Options to Support Digitalization of Business Models during COVID-19. We acknowledge that universal, secure, and affordable connectivity, is a fundamental enabler for the digital economy as well as a catalyst for inclusive growth, innovation and sustainable development. We acknowledge the importance of data free flow with trust and cross-border data flows. We reaffirm the role of data for development. We support fostering an open, fair, and non-discriminatory environment, and protecting and empowering consumers, while addressing the challenges related to privacy, data protection, intellectual property rights, and security. By continuing to address these challenges, in accordance with relevant applicable legal frameworks, we can further facilitate data free flow and strengthen consumer and business trust. We recognize the importance of working with stakeholders to connect humanity by accelerating global internet penetration and bridging digital divides. We recognize the importance of promoting security in the digital economy and welcome the G20 Examples of Practices Related to Security in the Digital Economy. We will continue to promote multi-stakeholder discussions to advance innovation and a human-centered approach to Artificial Intelligence (AI), taking note of the Examples of National Policies to Advance the G20 AI Principles. We welcome both the G20 Smart Mobility Practices, as a contribution to the well-being and resilience of smart cities and communities, and the G20 Roadmap toward a Common Framework for Measuring the Digital Economy.


G20 Leaders Statement 2019 and AI


To further promote innovation in the digital economy, we support the sharing of good practices on effective policy and regulatory approaches and frameworks that are innovative as well as agile, flexible, and adapted to the digital era, including through the use of regulatory sandboxes. The responsible development and use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) can be a driving force to help advance the SDGs and to realize a sustainable and inclusive society. To foster public trust and confidence in AI technologies and fully realize their potential, we commit to a human-centered approach to AI, and welcome the non-binding G20 AI Principles, drawn from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Recommendation on AI. Further, we recognize the growing importance of promoting security in the digital economy and of addressing security gaps and vulnerabilities. We affirm the importance of protection of intellectual property. Along with the rapid expansion of emerging technologies including the Internet of Things (IoT), the value of an ongoing discussion on security in the digital economy is growing. We, as G20 members, affirm the need to further work on these urgent challenges. We reaffirm the importance of bridging the digital divide and fostering the adoption of digitalization among micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) and all individuals, particularly vulnerable groups and also encourage networking and experience-sharing among cities for the development of smart cities.

 

 

CAIDP Statements

 

.   . . We commend the G20 for the adoption of the AI Guidelines in 2019 and the Digital Minister’s commitment to Privacy Enhancing Technologies. We recognize the G20’s consistent emphasis on the need for human-centric and trustworthy AI and its support for the UNESCO Recommendations on AI Ethics. In past statements on AI, the G20 has aimed to foster public trust, create an open and fair environment, and safely advance innovation. The G20 has repeatedly committed to protecting vulnerable groups and fundamental freedoms. 

 

We acknowledge the accomplishments of the G20 in the field of AI policy. We support the C20 Policy Priorities inclusion of an emphasis on, “enhancing “ethical, safe, and fair technology”.  These priorities additionally include a commitment to “incentivize and mandate the generation of high-quality datasets for and from marginalised and underrepresented communities to correct biases in medical, financial, economic, and all generative AI applications.”  We commend the G20 for recognizing the importance of a “inclusive, human-centric, empowering, and sustainable digital transformation” and remaining committed to enabling data free flow with trust and promoting cross-border data flows in their 2022 Statement. 

 

Earlier this year, we recommended that G20 leaders establish “red lines” for specific AI deployments such as mass surveillance, predictive policing, biometric identification and social scoring, which violate fundamental human rights . We also asked that G20 leaders enact laws ensuring algorithmic transparency to promote trust and public safety and prohibit any deployment of lethal autonomous weapon systems. 

 

With the upcoming G20 Summit in New Delhi, we restate these points, as well as the following recommendations:

 

● Implement the G20 AI Guidelines. 

● Promote fairness, accountability, and transparency for AI systems, especially public services. 

● Establish best practices for AI procurement to protect fundamental rights. 

● Reduce the environmental impact of AI systems. 

● Adopt a regulatory framework for ethical impact assessments on AI systems to mitigate risks and avoid harm.  

 

We thank you for your consideration of our recommendations and welcome further discussions. 

 

The Center for AI and Digital Policy is a global research organization advising national governments and international organizations on AI and digital policy. Our aim is to promote democratic values, the rule of law, and fundamental rights. We publish an annual report that reviews and assesses AI policies and practices around the world.

 

We have closely followed the work of the G20 on AI policy. We have commended the G20 for the AI Guidelines (2019) and the commitment of the Digital Ministers to Privacy Enhancing Technologies that safeguard personal data. We also recognize the support of G20 nations for the UNESCO Recommendation on AI. The G20 Leaders Statements have repeatedly emphasized the need for human-centric and trustworthy AI.  

 

For the C20 2023, we recommend that civil society groups urge G20 leaders to endorse “red lines” for certain AI deployments that violate fundamental rights. These include social scoring, mass surveillance, predictive policing, and biometric categorization. We also ask the C20 to urge leaders to prohibit the deployment of lethal autonomous weapon systems. There is growing recognition around the world of the need for world leaders to address this challenge.

 

We also ask the C20 to encourage leaders to promote fairness, accountability, and transparency for all AI systems, particularly for public services. G20 leaders should adopt new laws to ensure algorithmic transparency and to limit algorithmic bias so that unfair treatment is not embedded in automated systems.

 

AI is shaping not simply our digital world but the opportunities for people around the world for employment, education, travel, credit, housing, and basic freedoms. Our leaders should ensure that these systems protect fundamental rights and public safety,

 

We hope that these recommendations will be incorporated in the C20 proposals for the G20 leaders. 

 

Earlier this year, the CAIDP wrote to the Members of the G20 Digital Economy Task Force (DETF) to express our support for the work of the G-20 in the field of AI policy.2 We noted positive outcomes from previous meetings of the G20, including the establishment of the G20 AI Guidelines. We also recommend that the G20 endorse “red lines” for certain AI deployments that violate fundamental freedoms. . . .

 

CAIDP further supports the C20 policy priorities in that “All policies, strategies and implementation must adopt a human rights-based, people-centered, equity-focused, and gender transformative lens.” We would like to point where AI systems can further deepen marginalization and widen inequalities for communities. A recent UN Report4 shows data used to guide AI systems can be faulty, discriminatory, out of date or irrelevant. This can create bias in AI systems with regards to gender and race. . . .

 

In CAIDP’s Statement to G-20 Digital Economy Task Force (DETF)6, we urged the G20 to focus on fairness, accountability, and transparency for all AI systems, particularly for public services. We emphasized the importance of protecting human rights, including social rights, in the context of AI systems deployed by public authorities. . . .

We write to you regarding Artificial Intelligence policies for the G20 nations and the upcoming G20 Rome Summit.1 We urge you to take concrete steps to ensure human-centric and trustworthy AI and to promote fairness, accountability, and transparency in digital technologies. We specifically endorse earlier recommendations of the G20 for an “open, fair and non-discriminatory environment,” and we call your attention to important work this year of the G20 engagement groups, including the C20 and the T20, as well as the Digital Economy Task Force.

 

We recommend that the G20 nations (1) issue a strong statement against algorithmic bias in the 2021 Leaders Statement, (2) establish “red lines” for certain AI practices, such as “social scoring” and remote biometric identification, and (3) establish AI procurement processes to protect fundamental rights. . . .

 

Earlier this year, the CAIDP wrote to the Members of the G20 Digital Economy Task Force (DETF) to express our support for the work of the G20.5 We recognized the important contributions of the G20, including (1) the establishment of the G20 AI Guidelines (2) the endorsement of Digital Free Flow with Trust (3) the DETF report on National Examples for AI, and (4) the G20 Leaders Statements which have repeatedly emphasized human-centric and trustworthy AI. . . .

 

 

CAIP renews its recommendation that the G20 establish “red lines” for certain AI practices, such as “social scoring” and remote biometric identification, . . .

 

 

CAIDP Urges the G20 to issue a strong statement against algorithmic bias in the 2021 Leaders Statement.

First, we express our support for the work of the G20 in the field of AI policy. We have followed closely the outcomes of the summits in Buenos Aires (2018), Osaka (2019), and Riyadh (2020). We recognize the important contributions of the G20, including (1) the establishment of the G20 AI Guidelines (based on the OECD AI Principles), (2) the endorsement of Digital Free Flow with Trust (the initiative of Prime Minister Abe), (3) the DETF report on National Examples for AI (prepared in 2020), and (4) the G20 Leaders Statements which have repeatedly emphasized human-centric and trustworthy AI.

 

Second, we recommend that the G20 endorse “red lines” for certain AI deployments that violate fundamental freedoms. These systems are contrary to the goals of human-centric and trustworthy AI, and will likely provoke further negative responses. We note that more than 100 Members of the European Parliament, across the political parties, recently endorsed red lines on uses of AI that compromise fundamental rights.

 

 

We also urge the G20 to focus on fairness, accountability, and transparency for all AI systems, particularly for public services. The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe has this week adopted a Declaration emphasizing the importance of protecting human rights, including social rights, in the context of AI systems deployed by public authorities.

 


AI and Democratic Values - The G20


The G20 is an international forum, made up of 19 countries and the European Union, representing the world’s major developed and emerging economies.[98] Together, the G20 members represent 85 % of global GDP, 75% of international trade and two-thirds of the world’s population. According to the OECD, because of its size and strategic importance, the G20 has a crucial role in setting the path for the future of global economic growth.

In the last few years, and in collaboration with the OECD, the G20 has taken a leading role in the promulgation of the global framework for AI policy. At the Osaka summit in 2019, former Prime Minister Abe and OECD Secretary General Gurria gathered support for the OECD AI Principles from the G20 countries. The preparatory work for the 2020 summit in Riyadh provided the first opportunity to assess progress toward implementation of the OECD AI Principles.[99]

 

In November 2020, the G20 Leaders Declaration addressed both Artificial Intelligence and the digital economy. On AI, the G20 nations said, “We will continue to promote multi-stakeholder discussions to advance innovation and a human-centered approach to Artificial Intelligence (AI), taking note of the Examples of National Policies to Advance the G20 AI Principles. We welcome both the G20 Smart Mobility Practices, as a contribution to the well-being and resilience of smart cities and communities, and the G20 Roadmap toward a Common Framework for Measuring the Digital Economy.”[100]

 

On the Digital Economy, the G20 said in 2020, “We acknowledge that universal, secure, and affordable connectivity, is a fundamental enabler for the digital economy as well as a catalyst for inclusive growth, innovation and sustainable development. We acknowledge the importance of data free flow with trust and cross-border data flows.” The G20 Declaration further said, “We support fostering an open, fair, and non-discriminatory environment, and protecting and empowering consumers, while addressing the challenges related to privacy, data protection, intellectual property rights, and security.”

 

The G20 advanced AI policy in the 2021 Leaders’ Declaration, issued at the conclusion of the Summit in Rome.[101] Recognizing the “benefits stemming from the responsible use and development of trustworthy human-centered Artificial Intelligence (AI),” the G20 Leaders said in Rome they would encourage competition and innovation, “as well as diversity and inclusion,” and the importance of international cooperation to promote research, development, and application of AI

In advance of the 2021 Summit, the G20 Digital Economy Ministers reaffirmed “their willingness to implement trustworthy Artificial Intelligence (AI) and to commit to a human-centered approach, as . . . guided by the G20 AI Principles, drawn from the OECD Recommendations on AI.”[102] The Ministers also noted that the “measurement of AI, notably its diffusion and impact across the economy and the international comparability of indicators on AI, needs to be improved.”

 

“Privacy and data protection” figured prominently in the 2021 G20 Leaders Statement with multiple references in policies concerning health and COVID, transportation and travel, the digital economy and higher education, data free flows with trust, and digital identity tools. The G20 Leaders also prioritized Gender Equality and Women’s Empowerment, a focus area for AI policy. And the G20 Leaders said they would work in 2022 “towards enhancing confidence in the digital environment by improving internet safety and countering online abuse, hate speech, online violence and terrorism while protecting human rights and fundamental freedoms.”

 

 FOOTNOTES

[98] OECD, What is the G20? https://www.oecd.org/g20/about/

[99] OECD G20 Digital Economy Task Force, Examples of AI National Policies (2020), https://www.mcit.gov.sa/sites/default/files/examples-of-ai-national-policies.pdf

[100] G20 Riyadh Summit, Leaders Declaration (Nov. 21-22, 2020), https://g20.org/en/media/Documents/G20%20Riyadh%20Summit%20Leaders%20Declar ation_EN.pdf

[101] G20 Information Centre, G20 Rome Leaders' Declaration (Oct. 31, 2021), http://www.g20.utoronto.ca/2021/211031-declaration.html

[102] G20 Information Centre, Declaration of G20 Digital Ministers: Leveraging Digitalisation for a Resilient, Strong, Sustainable and Inclusive Recovery (Aug. 5, 2021), http://www.g20.utoronto.ca/2021/210805-digital.html


CAIDP Updates